http://www.lunixmonster.org/forums/index.php?showtopic=1500MUST we have two threads?
Like I said in there, it's a generic game, with generic graphics, generic gameplay, etc. The only thing I found really interesting was the squad equipment/reinforcement, and the reinforcements ends up crippling you rather then helping.
I find the first two pictures to be remarkably better looking. DOW looks lowpoly and lowres. The tank driver in GC2 has more detail on his face then the Space Marines do on their entire body (The guns the Space Marines are holding are largely solid blocks with a gun-like texture on it, the marines in GC2 have actual modeled guns. I find the lack of texture detail despicable, especially on the backpacks. The Assault Marines are as boring as you can get. Which surprises me since Homeworld 2 was a feast for the eyes.)